SEP 30, 2022 8:00 AM PDT

Paper About Room Temperature Superconductivity Retracted from Nature

WRITTEN BY: Hannah Daniel

Nature has retracted a groundbreaking paper demonstrating superconductivity at room temperature.

We’ve written about the discovery before and the debate around its legitimacy. Published in October 2020 in Nature, researchers led by Ranga Dias at the University of Rochester showed that their solid carbon, sulfur, and hydrogen compound could exhibit superconductivity—zero energy loss as current passes through it—at 14°C, just under room temperature.

Superconductors have many practical applications, including everyday items like motors, generators, and transformers, as well as medical Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance devices. With superconductors, we could transfer electrical energy from one point to another without losing any energy, but this has never been demonstrated outside of a lab.

In the past, superconductivity has only been observed at temperatures just above absolute zero because there is almost no electrical resistance in such extreme cold. This Is one of the reasons that some physicists doubted the discovery.

They wondered if some of the principles of superconductivity were able to be tested with the research team’s setup, and one group even asked the authors to see the unprocessed data. However, Dias’s group refused, and Nature had to add disclaimers to the original article.

The retraction of the paper came after Nature editors investigated the data analysis. The group used a “nonstandard procedure” when subtracting noise from the experimental data. Since the technique wasn’t explained in the paper, it led to questions about the validity of the results.

Dias responded, expressing his “disappointment” in the Nature editors, but reaffirmed that the retraction didn’t question the “observed physical superconductivity state,” he said in a statement.

Dias and his team plan to resubmit the paper with the original data included.

Sources: Nature, Phys.Org

About the Author
BS Biology
Hannah Daniel (she/they) is a recent graduate of Carnegie Mellon University, where she received a Bachelor of Science in Biology with an additional minor in Creative Writing. Currently, she works as a reporter for Informa Intelligence's Medtech Insight publication, a business newsletter detailing the latest innovations and regulations in the medical device industry.
You May Also Like
OCT 13, 2022
Technology
Four-Legged Robots Allowed to Run in The Wild Thanks to New Algorithms
OCT 13, 2022
Four-Legged Robots Allowed to Run in The Wild Thanks to New Algorithms
In a recent study that will be presented at the 2022 International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS) i ...
OCT 25, 2022
Earth & The Environment
US Economy Might Not Be Able to Recoup Future Hurricane Economic Impacts
OCT 25, 2022
US Economy Might Not Be Able to Recoup Future Hurricane Economic Impacts
In a recent study published in Environmental Research Letters, an international team of researchers led by the Potsdam I ...
NOV 03, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Martian Core Identified Through Planetary Scan
NOV 03, 2022
Martian Core Identified Through Planetary Scan
In a recent study published in Nature Astronomy, a pair of researchers from The Australian National University (ANU) hav ...
NOV 04, 2022
Earth & The Environment
Grad Student Highlights: Ian McDowell (University of Nevada, Reno)
NOV 04, 2022
Grad Student Highlights: Ian McDowell (University of Nevada, Reno)
This interview series is focused on the graduate student experience across all STEM fields that allows them to get their ...
NOV 17, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Astronomers Measure Size of 11-Billion-Year-Old Star
NOV 17, 2022
Astronomers Measure Size of 11-Billion-Year-Old Star
In a recent study published in Nature, an international team of researchers led by the University of Minnesota successfu ...
NOV 21, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Neutron Star Structure Could be Similar to Chocolate Pralines
NOV 21, 2022
Neutron Star Structure Could be Similar to Chocolate Pralines
A group of scientists at the Goethe University Frankfurt recently published two articles about their work on determining ...
Loading Comments...