FEB 17, 2025 10:07 AM PST

Can Sugar Negate All Positive Effects of Coffee?

WRITTEN BY: Greta Anne

A recent study published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition examined the relationship between coffee consumption and the risk of type 2 diabetes (T2D), with a specific focus on the effects of various coffee additives, including cream, sugar, artificial sweeteners, and coffee whiteners. The study analyzed data from three large prospective cohort studies, offering valuable insights into long-term coffee consumption patterns and their metabolic implications.

The study found that increasing coffee consumption by one cup per day was associated with a 10% reduction in the risk of developing T2D when the coffee was consumed without any additives. This reinforces previous findings that coffee, particularly in its pure form, has potential health benefits. However, when sugar or artificial sweeteners were added, the inverse association between coffee consumption and T2D risk was significantly weakened. This suggests that the metabolic effects of sugar and artificial sweeteners may counteract the benefits of coffee in diabetes prevention.

Interestingly, the study did not observe any association between the use of cream and the risk of diabetes. This is particularly notable given that cream is high in saturated fat, a macronutrient often linked to metabolic disorders. The researchers pointed out that evidence linking saturated fat consumption to T2D remains inconclusive.  

The study also indicated that coffee whiteners might reduce the protective effects of coffee against T2D, though this effect did not reach statistical significance. The researchers noted that coffee whiteners are a diverse group of products with varying compositions, often containing glucose, fat, and other additives. As a result, their metabolic effects could depend on the specific product used and the quantity consumed. Given the low prevalence of coffee whitener use among participants, more research is needed to draw firm conclusions.

The study’s findings highlight the potential benefits of coffee consumption in reducing T2D risk, particularly when consumed without additives. The results suggest that adding sugar or artificial sweeteners to coffee may counteract its protective effects, making it advisable for individuals at risk of diabetes to minimize or avoid these additives. 

For individuals looking to optimize their coffee consumption for health benefits, these findings reinforce the importance of drinking coffee without high-caloric or artificial additives. Public health recommendations may need to emphasize not only the benefits of coffee but also the risks associated with commonly used additives. By making small adjustments to daily coffee habits, individuals may be able to harness its potential protective effects against type 2 diabetes while minimizing metabolic risks.

Source: The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition

About the Author
Doctor of Pharmacy (PharmD)
Greta holds her PharmD and is a writer at Labroots. She also has a strong background in neuroscience & psychology. When she is not working as a pharmacist or a writer, she enjoys fostering her creative initiatives such as traveling, working out, spending time at the beach, and cooking!
You May Also Like
Loading Comments...